Is Alimony Always Tax Deductible to the Person Who Pays It?
|
By Law Offices of Linda A. Kerns
Published: February 20, 2006 |
Generally, alimony is tax deductible to the person who pays it and this can result in a significant tax savings for the payor (person who pays alimony) as well as a tax bill for the payee (person who receives the alimony). This means that if you pay alimony, you may get an income tax deduction. If you receive alimony, you may owe income taxes.
However, just because a payment is called "alimony" does not mean that the Internal Revenue Service will agree. In fact, the Internal Revenue Code defines "alimony" or "separate maintenance payments." In Pennsylvania and New Jersey, common terms also include spousal support, alimony pendente lite, and maintenance. No matter what the payment is called, the analysis must be performed under the statute.
The statute requires that the payment must be in cash. This is important because some spouses make arrangements, early in the separation, for one of the spouses to directly pay bills for the other, such as the mortgage and household bills. Because one spouse is not paying cash to the other spouse, these payments would probably not be considered alimony.
The payment must be "received by.... a spouse under a divorce or separation instrument." This means that there must be some type of writing that qualifies as a divorce or separation instrument. This could include a court order, a written separation agreement, or a property settlement agreement. In the instrument, the amount of the payment should be specified, as well as the frequency of the payment and language stating that the payment is for the support of the spouse, as opposed to the support of any children of the relationship.
The divorce or separation instrument must exclude language that states that the payment is not includible in gross income or not deductible to the payee spouse. To be considered alimony, the spouses may not be members of the same household at the time that the payment is made. The liability to make the payments must cease at the death of the payee spouse and there must not be an arrangement to continue any payments or substitute payments after death of the payee spouse.
The tax savings from deducting alimony payments can provide an economic boost to the payor spouse at a time when resources are stretched. Separation and divorce usually involve taking the same amount of income that supported one intact family to fund two separate households. Tax deductibility of the payments is a way to stretch the income. An accountant can assist the payor spouse with adjusting the withholding tax from the paychecks so that less tax is withheld from each paycheck and therefore more cash is available for immediate spending.
When there are minor children involved, any support order usually contains two components: support for the spouse and support for the children. Support of children versus spouses is treated differently for tax purposes. Child support is not taxable to the payee or deductible for the payor. Recently, the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit was faced with a case where a court order did not specify which portion of the support order was for child support and which portion was for spousal support. This is known as an unallocated order. In Patricia Kean v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, the wife received varying amounts of support from the husband pursuant to court orders. The language of the court orders stated that the support was for the purpose of maintaining the wife, the children, and the household. However, there was no other language that specifically apportioned the payments between the wife and children. Ultimately, even though a portion of these payments were intended for the support of the children, the court considered the entire sum to be alimony, and therefore taxable to the wife. In this particular case, the wife ended up owing a significant amount in taxes.
As this case demonstrates, tax consequences should be considered with regard to any support order as taxes owed (or taxes deducted) can have significant financial consequences. An accountant can analyze the tax effects.

