How is spousal support
(alimony) determined?
Spousal support is not part of the property
settlement, but is considered separately, after the property has been divided. The goals of spousal support are to balance
the incomes and needs of the parties so that neither person’s standard of
living is greatly affected, and to support the recipient spouse in becoming
self-sufficient. The courts consider a number of factors in deciding whether to
award spousal support, and must make findings on each factor that is relevant. These
factors include:
- Past
Relations and Conduct of the Parties: The court may
consider the conduct or “fault” of the party during the marriage (such as
infidelity or substance abuse), even though Michigan is a no-fault divorce
state.
- Length of
the Marriage: The fact that a marriage was long-term (10 years or more) is
especially relevant where one spouse has no career or marketable skills.
- Ability
to Work: Courts have ruled that an award of temporary spousal support
is unfair where there is serious doubt about a spouse's ability to become fully
self-supporting after an award of temporary spousal support has expired; a
longer-term support arrangement is likely in that case.
- Source
and Amount of Property Awarded: The focus here is on
the earning potential of the marital assets awarded to the recipient spouse,
especially when both parties have substantial assets and there is a large
disparity in their respective incomes. If the assets aren’t going to generate
income, then the judge may award support, on the basis that a person should not
have to dissipate a property award in order to pay for necessities.
- Ages of
the Parties: An older spouse will have a more difficult time becoming
self-supporting after a long marriage and the court will take this into account.
- Ability
to Pay: The ability to pay spousal support includes the earning
capacity of the paying spouse. Where one spouse intentionally fails to earn as much
as possible in order to avoid paying support, the judge may order that spouse
to pay based on imputed income, meaning whatever is the judge’s idea of what
the person could earn.
- Present
Situation of the Parties: Looks at the effect of different factors
on present ability to pay and the present or anticipated needs of the spouse
seeking support.
- Present
and Future Needs of the Parties: The court must
evaluate the combined effect of various factors on present and future needs of
the spouse seeking support.
- Health of
the Parties: Health is relevant to the ability to work and the personal
needs of the spouse seeking support, as well as the supporting spouse’s ability
to continue paying.
- Marital
Standard of Living: One purpose of spousal support is to ensure that both
partners continue to live in a manner consistent with how they lived during the
marriage, to the extent possible. Given that the same amount of money that was
being used to support one household now must spread to two, this isn’t always
possible, but it is the goal.
- General
Principles of Equity: Courts can use any other factor they wish in determining
what amount of alimony is fair, and deciding how long alimony should last.
If I get a support award, how long will it last?
To decide the duration of spousal support,
judges look at factors such as:
- The duration
of the marriage;
- Each
party’s contributions to the marital estate;
- Both
spouses’ ages;
- Both
spouses' health;
- The parties'
station in life during the marriage;
- The parties'
needs and circumstances; and
- The
paying party’s ongoing ability to pay and the recipient spouse’s likelihood of
becoming self-supporting.
Can spousal support
payments be modified?
Judges may modify spousal support orders in
Michigan. But the right to ask for a change in spousal support is a right that
can be waived (given up). When spouses include a statement in the divorce
judgment saying that the spousal support provision is binding and nonmodifiable,
they have both waived their rights to ask for a change.
However, waivers can only exist where there’s a consent
judgment, meaning that the spouses have negotiated their own settlement terms.
When the court enters a judgment after a trial, it can’t make spousal support
nonmodifiable. Where spousal support is modifiable, the person making the
request must show that there has been a significant change of circumstances,
and has to show evidence of the change, such as the loss of a home or job,
serious illness, or unexpected expenses of some kind.
When does spousal support
end?
When spouses agree to
a divorce settlement, the settlement agreement often includes a specified list
of circumstances that would cause spousal support to end. Usually these include
remarriage (or sometimes cohabitation) of the person being supported, death of
either spouse, or a specific event, like the supported spouse earning a degree
or certificate that should lead to gainful employment.
If the judgment doesn’t
specify events that cause support to end, remarriage and cohabitation don’t
automatically lead to a termination of support. However, support will end if the
paying spouse can show that the other spouse engaged in fraud or duress in the
process of negotiating the settlement. A judge might terminate support if the
paying spouse can show a significant change in ability to pay.